Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- creating:syntax [2025/03/29 13:36] – Second draft of scanning tutorial ahelwer
+++ creating:syntax [2025/03/29 22:57] (current) – Moved scanning tutorial to different page; this page will be about parsing ahelwer
@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 ====== Parsing TLA⁺ Syntax ======
-TLA⁺ is a large, complicated, and ambiguous language that takes a huge amount of work to parse correctly & completely.
-This is assisted by [[https://github.com/tlaplus/rfcs/tree/2a772d9dd11acec5d7dedf30abfab91a49de48b8/language_standard/tests/tlaplus_syntax|a comprehensive test corpus]] exercising the language's nooks & crannies, but here we will make life easy on ourselves.
-This tutorial only uses a minimal subset of TLA⁺ syntax, enough to handle [[https://github.com/tlaplus/Examples/blob/37236893f14527b4fc9f3963891eb2316c3de62e/specifications/DieHard/DieHarder.tla|the generalized DieHard spec]] with some inconvenience.
-While that may seem limiting, this tutorial tries to focus on the difficult & interesting parts of bringing TLA⁺ to life instead of more mundane drudgework like handling all hundred-some user-definable operator symbols.
-You are encouraged to extend this minimal core as you wish; language tooling is best developed incrementally!
-Slowly filling in the details of this rough language sketch has a satisfying meditative aspect.
-Here is what our minimal language subset includes:
-  * Named operator definitions like ''op == ...'' and ''op(x, y, z) == ...''
-  * Single-line comments like ''\* comment text''
-  * Declaration of ''VARIABLES''
-  * Finite set literals, like ''{1, 2, 3, 4, 5}''
-  * Quantification over sets with ''\E'' and ''\A''
-  * Function construction and application, like ''[e \in S |-> op(e)]'' and ''f[e]''
-  * The ''ENABLED'' and logical negation (''~'') prefix operators
-  * Some infix operators: ''\in'', ''='', ''+'', ''-'', ''..'', and ''<''
-  * The variable-priming suffix operator
-  * Vertically-aligned conjunction & disjunction lists
-  * The ''IF''/''THEN''/''ELSE'' construct
-  * Whole natural numbers like ''0'', ''5'', ''10'', etc.
-  * Boolean values ''TRUE'' and ''FALSE''
-Notably, we do not use the familiar ''---- MODULE Name ----''/''===='' encapsulation.
-Files simply consist of a series of unit-level TLA⁺ definitions.
-We also do not leave room for a separate model configuration file; all ''CONSTANT'' values must instead be hardcoded, and well-known names like ''Init'', ''Next'', ''TypeOK'', and ''Inv'' identify important definitions.
-As outlined above, you are free to add missing features (or even your own invented features!) as you wish.
-==== Preparation ====
-Read part I (the first three chapters) of free online textbook //[[https://craftinginterpreters.com/contents.html|Crafting Interpreters]]// by Robert Nystrom.
-We will be closely following the material in this book, modifying it to our uses.
-The first two chapters are a nice introduction and overview of language implementation generally.
-Chapter three specifies a toy language called Lox, to be used as an object of study for the remainder of the book.
-Our minimal TLA⁺ subset has some similarity to Lox with regard to expressions involving integers and booleans, but also differences - you can skip the section on closures (unless you want to implement higher-order operator parameters yourself) and the section on classes.
-What's important is that it's similar enough for all the fundamentals to still apply!
-Code snippets are shown often in this tutorial.
-When a snippet is similar to code given in the book with the exception of a few lines, the differing lines will be highlighted.
-Highlighting is also used to identify //new// code being added to a large section of code given previously, with surrounding lines included for context.
-Sometimes the code given here is so different from that provided by the book that highlighting is simply ommitted to reduce visual noise.
-A parenthetical will specify the meaning of highlighted code when ambiguous.
-==== Section 4.1: The Interpreter Framework ====
-[[https://craftinginterpreters.com/a-tree-walk-interpreter.html|Part II:: A Tree-Walk Interpreter]] is where we start to merge with and modify the given code.
-Everything in [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#the-interpreter-framework|section 4.1]] can be left unchanged from what's given, although of course it makes sense to change some of the names from "Lox" to "TlaPlus" or similar.
-You should thus have followed along and arrived at something similar to the below file ''TlaPlus.java'':
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="1,11"]>
-package com.craftinginterpreters.tla;
-import java.io.BufferedReader;
-import java.io.IOException;
-import java.io.InputStreamReader;
-import java.nio.charset.Charset;
-import java.nio.file.Files;
-import java.nio.file.Paths;
-import java.util.List;
-public class TlaPlus {
-  static boolean hadError = false;
-  public static void main(String[] args) throws IOException {
-    if (args.length > 1) {
-      System.out.println("Usage: jlox [script]");
-      System.exit(64);
-    } else if (args.length == 1) {
-      runFile(args[0]);
-    } else {
-      runPrompt();
-    }
-  }
-  private static void runFile(String path) throws IOException {
-    byte[] bytes = Files.readAllBytes(Paths.get(path));
-    run(new String(bytes, Charset.defaultCharset()));
-    // Indicate an error in the exit code.
-    if (hadError) System.exit(65);
-  }
-  private static void runPrompt() throws IOException {
-    InputStreamReader input = new InputStreamReader(System.in);
-    BufferedReader reader = new BufferedReader(input);
-    for (;;) {
-      System.out.print("> ");
-      String line = reader.readLine();
-      if (line == null) break;
-      run(line);
-      hadError = false;
-    }
-  }
-  private static void run(String source) {
-    Scanner scanner = new Scanner(source);
-    List<Token> tokens = scanner.scanTokens();
-    // For now, just print the tokens.
-    for (Token token : tokens) {
-      System.out.println(token);
-    }
-  }
-  static void error(int line, String message) {
-    report(line, "", message);
-  }
-  private static void report(int line, String where,
-                             String message) {
-    System.err.println(
-        "[line " + line + "] Error" + where + ": " + message);
-    hadError = true;
-  }
-}
-</code>
-==== Section 4.2: Lexemes and Tokens ====
-The ''TokenType'' class in [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#lexemes-and-tokens|section 4.2]] is our first major departure from the book.
-Instead of Lox tokens, we use the atomic components of our minimal TLA⁺ language subset defined above.
-Adapting the snippet in [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#token-type|section 4.2.1]] we get:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true"]>
-package com.craftinginterpreters.tla;
-enum TokenType {
-  // Single-character tokens.
-  LEFT_PAREN, RIGHT_PAREN, LEFT_BRACE, RIGHT_BRACE,
-  LEFT_BRACKET, RIGHT_BRACKET, COMMA, COLON,
-  MINUS, PLUS, LESS_THAN, NEGATION, PRIME,
-  // Short fixed-length tokens.
-  EQUAL, EQUAL_EQUAL, AND, OR, DOT_DOT, ALL_MAP_TO,
-  // Literals.
-  IDENTIFIER, NAT_NUMBER, TRUE, FALSE,
-  // Keywords.
-  VARIABLES, ENABLED, IF, THEN, ELSE,
-  // Symbols.
-  IN, EXISTS, FOR_ALL,
-  EOF
-}
-</code>
-There is a very minor design decision here, of the type encountered innumerable times when writing a parser.
-TLA⁺ includes boolean values ''TRUE'' and ''FALSE'', but we don't //need// to give them their own token types; they can be parsed as ordinary ''IDENTIFIER'' tokens then later resolved to the built-in operators ''TRUE'' and ''FALSE''.
-However, since we are writing our interpreter in Java and Java has primitive boolean literals, it is convenient to add specialized tokens for ''TRUE'' and ''FALSE'' so we can resolve them to primitive Java values on the spot.
-The existing TLA⁺ tools do not take this approach, and instead later resolve the identifiers ''TRUE'' and ''FALSE'' from a set of built-in operators.
-This sort of works-either-way design dilemma occurs often, and we will see it again when trying to decide whether to disallow a snippet of invalid TLA⁺ at the syntactic or semantic level.
-In [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#location-information|section 4.2.3]], we make one //very critical// addition to the information about each token tracked in the ''Token'' class: the token's start column.
-This will come in useful when parsing vertically-aligned conjunction & disjunction lists.
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="8,10,15"]>
-package com.craftinginterpreters.tla;
-class Token {
-  final TokenType type;
-  final String lexeme;
-  final Object literal;
-  final int line;
-  final int column;
-  Token(TokenType type, String lexeme, Object literal, int line, int column) {
-    this.type = type;
-    this.lexeme = lexeme;
-    this.literal = literal;
-    this.line = line;
-    this.column = column;
-  }
-  public String toString() {
-    return type + " " + lexeme + " " + literal;
-  }
-}
-</code>
-==== Section 4.4: The Scanner Class ====
-We now move on to the very important ''Scanner'' class in [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#the-scanner-class|section 4.4]].
-Our first modification to the code given in the book is to track the column in addition to the line, mirroring our addition to the ''Token'' class:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="1,8,16,29"]>
-package com.craftinginterpreters.tla;
-import java.util.ArrayList;
-import java.util.HashMap;
-import java.util.List;
-import java.util.Map;
-import static com.craftinginterpreters.tla.TokenType.*;
-class Scanner {
-  private final String source;
-  private final List<Token> tokens = new ArrayList<>();
-  private int start = 0;
-  private int current = 0;
-  private int line = 1;
-  private int column = 0;
-  Scanner(String source) {
-    this.source = source;
-  }
-  List<Token> scanTokens() {
-    while (!isAtEnd()) {
-      // We are at the beginning of the next lexeme.
-      start = current;
-      scanToken();
-    }
-    tokens.add(new Token(EOF, "", null, line, column));
-    return tokens;
-  }
-  private boolean isAtEnd() {
-    return current >= source.length();
-  }
-}
-</code>
-==== Section 4.5: Recognizing Lexemes ====
-[[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#recognizing-lexemes|Section 4.5]] finally gets around to actually handling text input!
-Of course, our unambiguous single-character lexing code in ''scanToken'' has some differences (including the removal of Lox tokens ''DOT'', ''SEMICOLON'', and ''STAR'').
-Note also that we increment the column position in ''advance()'', and there is some index arithmetic necessary when adding a token as we must calculate the token's start column:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="8,9,11,14,15,16,18,24,34,35",start_line_numbers_at=37]>
-  private void scanToken() {
-    char c = advance();
-    switch (c) {
-      case '(': addToken(LEFT_PAREN); break;
-      case ')': addToken(RIGHT_PAREN); break;
-      case '{': addToken(LEFT_BRACE); break;
-      case '}': addToken(RIGHT_BRACE); break;
-      case '[': addToken(LEFT_BRACKET); break;
-      case ']': addToken(RIGHT_BRACKET); break;
-      case ',': addToken(COMMA); break;
-      case ':': addToken(COLON); break;
-      case '-': addToken(MINUS); break;
-      case '+': addToken(PLUS); break;
-      case '<': addToken(LESS_THAN); break;
-      case '~': addToken(NEGATION); break;
-      case '\'': addToken(PRIME); break;
-      default:
-        TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        break;
-    }
-  }
-  private char advance() {
-    column++;
-    return source.charAt(current++);
-  }
-  private void addToken(TokenType type) {
-    addToken(type, null);
-  }
-  private void addToken(TokenType type, Object literal) {
-    String text = source.substring(start, current);
-    int start_column = column - (current - start);
-    tokens.add(new Token(type, text, literal, line, start_column));
-  }
-}
-</code>
-Moving on to lexing short fixed-length tokens, the differences widen considerably; we want to lex ''='', ''=='', ''/\'', ''\/'', ''..'', and ''|->'' (new code highlighted):
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19",start_line_numbers_at=52]>
-      case '\'': addToken(PRIME); break;
-      case '=':
-        addToken(match('=') ? EQUAL_EQUAL : EQUAL);
-        break;
-      case '\\':
-        if (match('/')) {
-          addToken(OR);
-        } else {
-          TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        }
-        break;
-      case '/':
-        if (consume('\\')) addToken(AND);
-        break;
-      case '.':
-        if (consume('.')) addToken(DOT_DOT);
-        break;
-      case '|':
-        if (consume('-') && consume('>')) addToken(ALL_MAP_TO);
-        break;
-      default:
-        TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        break;
-</code>
-Two helper methods are used: the first, ''match(char)'', is given in the text.
-We have to modify it slightly by updating the value of ''column'' if ''current'' advances.
-The second helper method is of our own invention.
-''consume(char)'' is similar to ''match(char)'' but logs an error if the expected character is not found.
-You might be wondering why we didn't write the ''\'' case using ''consume(char)'', and that's because we will very shortly be adding to it.
-<code java [highlight_lines_extra="5,10,11,12,13,14"]>
-  private boolean match(char expected) {
-    if (isAtEnd()) return false;
-    if (source.charAt(current) != expected) return false;
-    column++;
-    current++;
-    return true;
-  }
-  private boolean consume(char expected) {
-    if (match(expected)) return true;
-    else TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-    return false;
-  }
-</code>
-==== Section 4.6: Longer Lexemes ====
-In [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#longer-lexemes|section 4.6]] we learn how to handle lexemes of longer or unlimited length.
-Let's begin with single-line comments, which in TLA⁺ start with ''\*'' (new code highlighted):
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="4,5,6",start_line_numbers_at=56]>
-      case '\\':
-        if (match('/')) {
-          addToken(OR);
-        } else if (match('*')) {
-          // A comment goes until the end of the line.
-          while (peek() != '\n' && !isAtEnd()) advance();
-        } else {
-          TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        }
-        break;
-</code>
-This uses the ''peek()'' helper given in the book:
-<code java>
-  private char peek() {
-    if (isAtEnd()) return '\0';
-    return source.charAt(current);
-  }
-</code>
-Also add the code to skip whitespace:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11",start_line_numbers_at=74]>
-      break;
-      case ' ':
-      case '\r':
-      case '\t':
-        // Ignore whitespace.
-        break;
-      case '\n':
-        line++;
-        break;
-      default:
-        TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        break;
-</code>
-Critically, we have to set ''column'' to zero when processing a newline.
-This is what makes column tracking work!
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="2",start_line_numbers_at=82]>
-      case '\n':
-        column = 0;
-        line++;
-        break;
-</code>
-We aren't supporting strings (unless you want to go the extra mile) so next up is numbers:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="2,3,4,5,6",start_line_numbers_at=87]>
-      default:
-        if (isDigit(c)) {
-          number();
-        } else {
-          TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        }
-        break;
-</code>
-This uses the ''isDigit(char)'' and ''number()'' helpers.
-We're only handling whole natural numbers, no decimals, so our ''number()'' method is much simpler than the one from the book:
-<code java>
-  private boolean isDigit(char c) {
-    return c >= '0' && c <= '9';
-  }
-  private void number() {
-    while (isDigit(peek())) advance();
-    addToken(NAT_NUMBER,
-        Integer.parseInt(source.substring(start, current)));
-  }
-</code>
-==== Section 4.7: Reserved Words and Identifiers ====
-In [[https://craftinginterpreters.com/scanning.html#reserved-words-and-identifiers|section 4.7]] we learn to lex general identifiers; start by modifying the ''default'' case of the ''scanToken()'' method:
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="4,5",start_line_numbers_at=87]>
-      default:
-        if (isDigit(c)) {
-          number();
-        } else if (isAlpha(c)) {
-          identifier();
-        } else {
-          TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        }
-</code>
-Then include these helper methods:
-<code java>
-  private void identifier() {
-    while (isAlphaNumeric(peek())) advance();
-    addToken(IDENTIFIER);
-  }
-  private boolean isAlpha(char c) {
-    return (c >= 'a' && c <= 'z') ||
-           (c >= 'A' && c <= 'Z') ||
-            c == '_';
-  }
-  private boolean isAlphaNumeric(char c) {
-    return isAlpha(c) || isDigit(c);
-  }
-</code>
-Note that this is //close// to TLA⁺ identifier rules, but not quite correct.
-TLA⁺ identifiers can be any sequence of alphanumeric ASCII characters including underscore, as long as at least one character in the sequence is alphabetical (''[a-zA-Z]'').
-You are encouraged to modify your code to match this constraint, but for simplicity we'll stick with the close-enough identifier logic given in the book.
-Fixing it requires modifying the number lexing logic from the previous section.
-Some valid identifiers are actually keywords and should be properly tokenized as such.
-So, define a keyword map:
-<code java>
-  private static final Map<String, TokenType> keywords;
-  static {
-    keywords = new HashMap<>();
-    keywords.put("ELSE",       ELSE);
-    keywords.put("ENABLED",    ELSE);
-    keywords.put("FALSE",      FALSE);
-    keywords.put("IF",         IF);
-    keywords.put("THEN",       THEN);
-    keywords.put("TRUE",       TRUE);
-    keywords.put("VARIABLE",   VARIABLES);
-    keywords.put("VARIABLES",  VARIABLES);
-  }
-</code>
-Then update our implementation of ''identifier()'' to first check whether an identifier is a keyword:
-<code java [highlight_lines_extra="4,5,6,7"]>
-  private void identifier() {
-    while (isAlphaNumeric(peek())) advance();
-    String text = source.substring(start, current);
-    TokenType type = keywords.get(text);
-    if (type == null) type = IDENTIFIER;
-    addToken(type);
-  }
-</code>
-We're nearly done!
-All we need to do is repeat the keyword map method for the LaTeX-style symbols ''\in'', ''\E'', and ''\A''.
-Start by adding yet another branch to the ''\'' case (it's getting quite crowded!):
-<code java [enable_line_numbers="true",highlight_lines_extra="7,8",start_line_numbers_at=56]>
-      case '\\':
-        if (match('/')) {
-          addToken(OR);
-        } else if (match('*')) {
-          // A comment goes until the end of the line.
-          while (peek() != '\n' && !isAtEnd()) advance();
-        } else if (isAlpha(peek())) {
-          symbol();
-        } else {
-          TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-        }
-        break;
-</code>
-Then define the symbol map and ''symbol()'' helper:
-<code java>
-  private static final Map<String, TokenType> symbols;
-  static {
-    symbols = new HashMap<>();
-    symbols.put("\\in",       IN);
-    symbols.put("\\E",        EXISTS);
-    symbols.put("\\exists",   EXISTS);
-    symbols.put("\\A",        FOR_ALL);
-    symbols.put("\\forall",   FOR_ALL);
-  }
-  private void symbol() {
-    while (isAlpha(peek())) advance();
-    String text = source.substring(start, current);
-    TokenType type = symbols.get(text);
-    if (type == null) TlaPlus.error(line, "Unexpected character.");
-    else addToken(type);
-  }
-</code>
-We are now done lexing our minimal TLA⁺ subset.
-Give it a whirl!
-Running your Java program should bring up the REPL, where you can enter input to see how it is lexed; for example:
-<code>
-> \A e \in S : P(e)
-FOR_ALL \A null
-IDENTIFIER e null
-IN \in null
-IDENTIFIER S null
-COLON : null
-IDENTIFIER P null
-LEFT_PAREN ( null
-IDENTIFIER e null
-RIGHT_PAREN ) null
-EOF  null
-</code>
-Isn't it amazing how quickly this is coming together?
-The simplicity of the required code is one of the great wonders of language implementation.